MathsClub Problems, proofs & good company

← All problems

The Boolean Pythagorean Triples Problem

historic

Posed by Ronald Graham (offering $100) · 1980 · combinatorics / satisfiability · resolved 2016

The problem

Is there a 2-colouring of \mathbb{N} (equivalently of {1,…,N} for all N) such that no Pythagorean triple (a² + b² = c²) is monochromatic? Answer: NO — every colouring fails by N = 7825, while {1,…,7824} admits valid colourings.

History & significance

Ronald Graham offered $100 for the answer in the 1980s, a question rooted in Schur-type partition regularity (Pythagorean triples are not partition regular — unlike Schur triples). Human techniques were hopeless: the statement quantifies over all colourings of infinitely constrained structure.