MathsClub Problems, proofs & good company

The Problems

Not schoolwork — the questions that resisted Erdős, Hilbert, and everyone since. The club keeps three shelves: what is still open, what AI recently settled, and what took humanity centuries.

Euler proved ζ(2) = π²/6 in 1735. Whether ζ(3) is rational stayed open for 243 years — until Roger Apéry announced a miraculous recurrence-driven proof at 64 years old.

Posed by question lineage via Euler's Basel problem · 1735 · number theory · resolved 1978

Should a set admit a Fourier basis exactly when it tiles by translations? Spectacularly false in dimension ≥ 3 — Terence Tao's counterexample — while the low-dimensional wreckage keeps generating theorems.

Posed by Bent Fuglede · 1974 · harmonic analysis / tiling theory · resolved 2003

Any dense subset of the n-dimensional tic-tac-toe board contains a whole line. Proven by the FIRST-ever Polymath project — dozens of mathematicians thinking in one comment thread.

Posed by proven collaboratively; conjectured lineage via Furstenberg–Katznelson · 2009 · extremal combinatorics · resolved 2012

An angel jumps k squares per move eating tiles; a devil burns one square forever. Can the angel escape forever? Conway offered $100 — four independent proofs arrived within months in 2006.

Posed by John H. Conway · 1996 · combinatorial game theory

Given a group presentation and a word, decide if the word equals the identity. Dehn asked for algorithms; logic answered that none can exist — for some groups.

Posed by Max Dehn · 1911 · mathematical logic / group theory

Are finitely generated groups of bounded exponent necessarily finite? No — wildly no — yet their RESTRICTED cousin said yes so profoundly it earned a Fields Medal.

Posed by William Burnside · 1902 · group theory

Among all closed surfaces in 3-space, does the Clifford torus minimise bending energy (∫ H²)? Proven by min-max theory fifty years later, in work that revived geometric measure theory.

Posed by Thomas Willmore · 1965 · differential geometry

Can pure states extend uniquely to a bigger algebra? A quantum-measurement question from 1959, resolved in 2013 by undergraduates-will-understand polynomial inequalities — with ripple effects across engineering.

Posed by Richard Kadison / Isadore Singer · 1959 · operator algebras / combinatorics

Counting solutions of equations over finite fields should follow deep topology: zeta functions satisfy RH-analogues because varieties behave like classical manifolds. Deligne's 1974 proof reshaped everything.

Posed by André Weil · 1949 · algebraic geometry / number theory

How often can the SAME integer appear in Pascal's triangle? Singmaster guessed a uniform bound; the number 3003 appears six times and nobody can rule out seven.

Posed by David Singmaster · 1975 · combinatorial number theory

Does a box exist with integer edges, integer face diagonals AND integer space diagonal? Three centuries of searching; not one example, no proof of impossibility.

· Diophantine geometry

A precise promise problem about labelling cycles of pairwise consistency checks that is believed (was believed?) NP-hard — and became the load-bearing assumption for half of optimal-inapproximability theory.

Posed by Subhash Khot · 2002 · theoretical computer science

How many sets of size w force a sunflower (petals meeting pairwise in the same core)? Should be c^w; sixty-four years of effort moved the base from w down to O(log w) — never to a constant.

Posed by Paul Erdős / Richard Rado · 1960 · extremal combinatorics

Label any tree's vertices 1..n so that edge-differences are all distinct. Sixty years of near-misses culminated in November 2025: every large tree gets ALMOST there.

Posed by Anton Kotzig / Gerhard Ringel · 1963 · graph labelling

Smallest convex blanket covering EVERY set of diameter 1? Pál's 1920 regular hexagon has been shrinking for a century — most recently in 2024.

Posed by Henri Lebesgue · 1914 · convex geometry

Find the smallest-area blanket that can cover a unit-length curve no matter how it bends. Sister puzzle to our solved moving sofa — and still wide open.

Posed by Leo Moser · 1966 · combinatorial geometry

γ = lim(1+1/2+...+1/n − log n) ≈ 0.5772…: we cannot even prove it is IRRATIONAL, let alone transcendental. Mathematics' most embarrassing constant.

Posed by implicit in Leonhard Euler's work · 1735 · number theory

Describe ALL abelian extensions of a number field explicitly, the way roots of unity generate them for Q. Kronecker called it his 'dream of youth'; it built class field theory and still dreams on.

Posed by David Hilbert (after Leopold Kronecker) · 1900 · number theory

Algebraic subvarieties should be visible in étale cohomology: which cohomology classes come from actual cycles? The arithmetic mirror of the Hodge conjecture, and nearly as stubborn.

Posed by John Tate · 1965 · arithmetic geometry

Primes are equidistributed in arithmetic progressions on average up to modulus q^{1−ε} for EVERY ε — twice the reach of the Bombieri–Vinogradov theorem. Half the modern theory of primes leans on this doubling.

Posed by Peter D. T. A. Elliott / Heini Halberstam · 1968 · analytic number theory

The Liouville function λ(n) should look random: correlations \sum_{n≤x} λ(n+h_1)...λ(n+h_k) should be o(x) for any fixed shifts. Two-point progress exists; three points and beyond resist.

Posed by Sarvadaman Chowla · 1965 · analytic number theory

Bound the number of limit cycles of a polynomial vector field in terms of its degree. Over 120 years on, not even the quadratic case has a complete answer.

Posed by David Hilbert · 1900 · dynamical systems / ODE

Can ONE single shape tile the plane, but only aperiodically? Yes — the 13-sided "hat", found in 2023 by a hobbyist mathematician and his collaborators, ending a sixty-year quest.

· geometry / tiling theory · resolved 2023

Is the colouring cost of a tensor product of graphs always the cheaper factor\'s? Fifty-three years of belief ended with Yaroslav Shitov\'s three-page demolition.

Posed by Stephen Hedetniemi · 1966 · graph theory · resolved 2019

Must every bounded set in n-dimensional space split into n+1 pieces of smaller diameter? True in low dimensions — spectacularly false in high ones.

Posed by Karol Borsuk · 1933 · combinatorial geometry · resolved 1993

The E₈ and Leech lattices are THE tightest packings of balls in their dimensions — proven by Maryna Viazovska\'s magic modular-form functions in a fortnight that stunned mathematics.

· discrete geometry · resolved 2016

How wildly does the Riemann zeta function grow on the critical line? Lindelöf said barely at all — a consequence of RH that may be provable even without it.

Posed by Ernst Leonard Lindelöf · 1908 · analytic number theory

Every root of a polynomial with all roots in the unit disk should lie within distance 1 of SOME critical point. Gauss-Lucas says critical points live in the disk; Sendov asks for the finer choreography.

Posed by Blagovest Sendov · 1958 · complex analysis / polynomial roots

Can a graph drawn so that every edge meets every other edge exactly once have more edges than vertices? Conway bet $1,000 nobody finds one.

Posed by John H. Conway · 1969 · combinatorial geometry / graph drawing

How far apart can consecutive primes be? Cramér's probabilistic model says never much more than (log p)² — a prediction we cannot approach unconditionally.

Posed by Harald Cramér · 1936 · analytic number theory

How few distinct distances must n plane points determine? Guth and Katz nearly closed it in 2010 — leaving only a logarithm standing between us and the answer.

Posed by Paul Erdős · 1946 · combinatorial geometry / incidence geometry

The last survivor: after the three-variable case fell to a 216-character counterexample in 2026, the ORIGINAL two-variable Jacobian question remains open.

Posed by Heinz Otto Keller · 1939 · polynomial mappings / algebraic geometry

Can you always rebuild a graph from its deck of vertex-deleted cards? Ulam-style determinism for combinatorial structure — open for over eighty years.

Posed by Paul J. Kelly / Stanisław Ulam · 1941 · graph theory

Does every graph needing k colours contain k pairwise vertex-disjoint connected subgraphs mutually joined by edges? One conjecture that would explain ALL of colouring.

Posed by Hugo Hadwiger · 1943 · graph theory

A^x + B^y = C^z with all exponents greater than 2 forces a common factor among the bases. Fermat's Last Theorem's living descendant, with a million-dollar bounty.

Posed by Andrew Beal · 1993 · number theory

Perfect numbers equal the sum of their proper divisors. Euclid knew even ones come from Mersenne primes; whether an odd perfect number exists has outlived twenty-three centuries.

· number theory

How algebraically independent can exponentials of numbers be? The master key to transcendence — prove it and Lindemann-Weierstrass, four-exponentials and much more fall out at once.

Posed by Stephen Schanuel · 1965 · transcendental number theory

Why is there no formula in radicals for fifth-degree equations? Abel proved none exists; Galois explained exactly why — and invented group theory doing it.

· algebra · resolved 1824

Trisect the angle, double the cube, square the circle — compass and straightedge alone. Two millennia of failure resolved by nineteenth-century algebra: all three are impossible, and the proofs founded modern field theory.

· classical geometry / algebra · resolved 1882

Give an algorithm deciding whether a polynomial has integer roots. Impossible — and proving impossibility wove Diophantine equations, Fibonacci numbers and computability into one of the 20th century\'s great joint theorems.

Posed by David Hilbert · 1900 · mathematical logic / number theory · resolved 1970

Is there a cardinality strictly between the integers and the reals? The first Hilbert problem dissolved into independence: yes in Gödel\'s universe, no in Cohen\'s — and both are legitimate.

Posed by Georg Cantor · 1878 · set theory / foundations · resolved 1963

Must every infinite ±1 sequence contain arbitrarily long homogeneous arithmetic progressions? Yes — Terence Tao's six-page proof ended an 83-year-old favourite, catalysed by a Polymath experiment.

Posed by Paul Erdős · 1932 · combinatorics / number theory · resolved 2015

S(5) = 160: the integers 1..160 can be 5-coloured with no monochromatic solution to x + y = z, but 1..161 cannot. A century-old Ramsey constant pinned by SAT.

Posed by Issai Schur · 1916 · Ramsey theory / satisfiability · resolved 2017

In any tiling of space by unit cubes, must two cubes share a whole face? True up to dimension 6, false from 8 — dimension 7 held out until SAT solvers plus Lean closed it in 2020.

Posed by Otto-Hermann Keller · 1930 · geometry / discrete mathematics · resolved 2020

Can the integers be two-coloured with no monochromatic Pythagorean triple? No — and proving it required a 200-terabyte certificate, the largest proof in history at publication.

Posed by Ronald Graham (offering $100) · 1980 · combinatorics / satisfiability · resolved 2016

Which convex pentagons tile the plane? Exactly fifteen families — the final word delivered by Michaël Rao\'s exhaustive computer-assisted elimination.

Posed by Karl Reinhardt (problem lineage via Hilbert 18) · 1918 · geometry / tiling theory · resolved 2017

BB(5) = 47,176,870: the maximal steps a halting 5-state Turing machine can run. Determined by a decade-long collaborative quest, machine-checked in Coq.

Posed by Tibor Radó · 1962 · computability theory · resolved 2024

What is the largest area of a rigid shape that can negotiate an L-shaped corridor of unit width? Fifty-eight years of sofa-shaping ended with Jineon Baek's 119-page proof.

Posed by Leo Moser · 1966 · geometry · resolved 2024

Is the 4-sphere, up to diffeomorphism, the unique smooth closed simply-connected 4-manifold? Topology says yes; smooth structures say nobody knows — and dimension four is where smoothness goes feral.

· differential topology

Colour the edges of complete graphs red/blue: how large before a monochromatic K₅ is forced? For K₅ versus K₅ we know only 43 ≤ R(5,5) ≤ 48.

· Ramsey theory

In any non-empty family of sets closed under union, must some element appear in at least half the sets? Perhaps the simplest open statement in extremal set theory.

Posed by Péter Frankl · 1978 · combinatorics

What is the least exponent ω with n×n matrices multipliable in O(n^ω) operations? Fifty-six years of algebraic ingenuity brought ω from 3 down toward 2 — never reaching it.

Posed by Volker Strassen (framed by the 1969 breakthrough) · 1969 · algorithms / linear algebra

How large can a subset of F_3^n be containing no three-term arithmetic progression? Bounds have collapsed twice — once by the polynomial method, once to DeepMind's FunSearch.

· additive combinatorics

Can every fraction 4/n be written as a sum of exactly three unit fractions? Egyptian mathematics meets the distribution of prime factors.

Posed by Paul Erdős / Ernst G. Straus · 1948 · number theory

Does every simple closed curve in the plane contain four points forming a square? Over a century old, proven true for vast classes of curves, false for none.

Posed by Otto Toeplitz · 1911 · topology

How many colours suffice so that no two points exactly one unit apart share a colour? Between five and seven since 2018 — when Aubrey de Grey shook a 70-year-old stalemate.

· combinatorial geometry

n runners start together on a circular track, each with a distinct constant speed. Must every runner, at some moment, be strictly farther than 1/n of the track from all the others?

Posed by Jörg M. Wills / (popularised by Goddyn) · 1968 · dynamical systems / number theory

a + b = c: how large can the radical of abc be relative to c? A statement about the deep tension between addition and multiplication — and home of mathematics' most controversial claimed proof.

Posed by Joseph Oesterlé / David Masser · 1985 · number theory

Does every bounded linear operator on a Hilbert space send some non-trivial closed subspace to itself? Fifty years of counterexamples on wilder spaces, two unrefereed claims on Hilbert space itself — and still no verdict.

Posed by roots in von Neumann; modern form due to Paul Halmos · 1949 · functional analysis / operator theory

How small can a set be that contains a unit line segment pointing in every direction? Dimension three fell in 2025 in a proof hailed as a once-in-a-century achievement; dimension four and beyond remain open.

Posed by Sōichi Kakeya (needle problem); modern form via Besicovitch & Perron trees · 1917 · geometric measure theory / harmonic analysis

Every odd number greater than 5 is the sum of three primes. Two hundred seventy-one years from letter to theorem — the little sibling of our unsolved shelf's Goldbach entry.

Posed by Christian Goldbach · 1742 · number theory · resolved 2013

Grocers stack oranges in hexagonal layers for good reason: Kepler said no arrangement beats face-centred cubic packing at 74.05%. Proof took 387 years and a computer.

Posed by Johannes Kepler · 1611 · discrete geometry · resolved 1998

Is a simply-connected closed 3-manifold necessarily a sphere? Ninety-nine years, one recluse, and the only Millennium Prize ever claimed.

Posed by Henri Poincaré · 1904 · topology · resolved 2003

Four colours suffice for any map. The first major theorem proved by a computer — and the first mathematical controversy about what a proof is.

Posed by Francis Guthrie · 1852 · graph theory · resolved 1976

No positive integers satisfy xⁿ + yⁿ = zⁿ for n > 2. Three hundred fifty-eight years, ten million pages of attempted proofs, one margin note too long to contain.

Posed by Pierre de Fermat · 1637 · number theory · resolved 1995

How many colours force a monochromatic triangle? Erdős's fifty-year-old lower-bound challenge, resolved superexponentially by Astra.

Posed by Paul Erdős · 1970 · Ramsey theory · resolved 2026

Are the hyperfinite II₁ factor's matrix approximations unique — must certain groups be visible in their von Neumann algebras? Disproved by OpenAI's Astra model, ending a fifty-year expectation.

Posed by Alain Connes · 1976 · operator algebras · resolved 2026

Are all finitely generated groups approximable by finite ones? OpenAI's Astra model announces a construction proving not — resolving a central question of group theory.

Posed by Benjamin Weiss / Peter M. Neumann era formulations · 1999 · geometric group theory · resolved 2026

Sums of small independent random variables resist concentrating too sharply. A decade-plus-old conjecture, initially proved by ChatGPT — and by two independent teams the same day.

Posed by Uriel Feige · 2010 · probability / theoretical computer science · resolved 2026

Must a finite set of reals grow fast under addition or multiplication? Over the reals: no — a cascade begun by AI's unit-distance breakthrough. Over the integers the conjecture lives on.

Posed by Paul Erdős / Endre Szemerédi · 1983 · additive combinatorics · resolved 2026

Can every bridgeless graph be covered by circuits traversing each edge exactly twice? Yes — with at most eight loops. Settled by GPT-5.6 Sol after fifty years.

Posed by multiple, 1970s · 1970 · graph theory · resolved 2026

If a polynomial self-map of space has everywhere-invertible derivative, must it be globally invertible? False in three variables: a 216-character counterexample ended an 87-year hunt.

Posed by Heinz Otto Keller · 1939 · polynomial mappings / algebraic geometry · resolved 2026

How many pairs of n plane points can sit exactly one unit apart? Erdős guessed his grid was unbeatable. An AI model proved him wrong — the first prominent open problem resolved autonomously by AI.

Posed by Paul Erdős · 1946 · combinatorial geometry · resolved 2026

Give the quantum field theory behind the Standard Model a rigorous foundation, and explain why the gluon is massive despite being massless in the equations.

· mathematical physics · $1M Clay Millennium Prize

On algebraic varieties, the analytic topology and the algebraic geometry see the same cycles. Whether they truly align is one of geometry's deepest gaps.

Posed by William Vallance Douglas Hodge · 1950 · algebraic geometry · $1M Clay Millennium Prize

An elliptic curve has infinitely many rational points precisely when its L-function vanishes at s = 1. Deep arithmetic meets deep analysis.

Posed by Bryan Birch / Peter Swinnerton-Dyer · 1965 · arithmetic geometry · $1M Clay Millennium Prize

Do solutions of the equations that describe fluid motion always exist and stay smooth, or can they blow up? Mathematics has not caught up with the water in the glass.

· mathematical physics / PDE · $1M Clay Millennium Prize

There are infinitely many primes p such that p + 2 is also prime. Infinitely close, structurally — but unproven.

· number theory

Every even integer greater than 2 is the sum of two primes. The oldest surviving unsolved problem in number theory.

Posed by Christian Goldbach / Leonhard Euler · 1742 · number theory

Take any positive integer: halve it if even, else triple it and add one. Does the sequence always reach 1?

Posed by Lothar Collatz · 1937 · dynamical systems / number theory

If a solution can be checked quickly, can it also be found quickly? The question that organises theoretical computer science.

Posed by Stephen Cook / Leonid Levin · 1971 · computational complexity · $1M Clay Millennium Prize

All non-trivial zeros of the Riemann zeta function lie exactly on the critical line Re(s) = 1/2. The single most consequential open statement in pure mathematics.

Posed by Bernhard Riemann · 1859 · analytic number theory · $1M Clay Millennium Prize