MathsClub Problems, proofs & good company

← All problems

Existence of Non-Sofic Groups

AI-resolved

Posed by Benjamin Weiss / Peter M. Neumann era formulations · 1999 · geometric group theory · resolved 2026

The problem

A group is sofic if its Cayley graph can be approximated arbitrarily well by finite permutation graphs (Weiss, 2000, building on Gromov's 1999 definition). Every known family of groups is sofic. Question: does a non-sofic group exist?

History & significance

Soficity connects to stability of dynamical systems, the Gottschalk surjunctivity conjecture, and Connes's embedding problem. Twenty-five years of candidate obstructions (trace methods, determinant conjectures) all failed to separate any group from the finite world.